Should I Let My Students Use ChatGPT?

As artificial intelligence (AI) tools like ChatGPT become more accessible, educators face a critical question: Should students use AI in the classroom? The short answer is yes—AI can be a powerful educational tool when used correctly. Much like how calculators have become essential in math classes, AI is becoming a staple in learning environments. The future of AI in education is not about avoidance but about responsible integration.

However, there are valid concerns. How can educators ensure AI fosters learning rather than replaces critical thinking? What safeguards can be put in place to prevent overreliance or misuse? This blog explores the ethical use of AI in education, how AI can help students, and how teachers can balance technology with traditional learning methods.

Why AI Tools Belong in the Classroom

Preparing Students for the Future

The workforce is rapidly evolving, and AI literacy for students is becoming a necessity. According to a 2023 survey, 56% of respondents reported using generative AI tools for work tasks, with 31% using them frequently and 25% occasionally. Workers most commonly use AI for drafting written content (68%), brainstorming (60%), and background research (50%). Given that this survey is nearly two years old, these numbers are likely even higher today. From business and healthcare to software development and marketing, AI is becoming a standard part of many industries.

‍

‍

By introducing AI tools like ChatGPT in classrooms, we equip students with the skills they’ll need to thrive in future careers. The use of AI in the classroom shouldn’t be viewed as a shortcut to completing assignments but rather as a learning aid—one that students will eventually be expected to use in their professional lives.

AI as a Learning Aid, Not a Replacement for Thinking

When used effectively, teaching with ChatGPT can enhance student learning. Think of AI as an interactive textbook—a tool that can answer questions, clarify complex topics, and provide instant feedback. Additionally, custom-built GPTs designed for specific educational purposes are becoming more common. These specialized AI tools can be tailored to reinforce subject-specific skills, provide personalized tutoring experiences, or even align with particular curriculum standards. As AI technology advances, educators have more opportunities to harness tools that are purpose-built for learning.

Examples Uses of AI in Education:

• History: Instead of just reading about the Civil War, students can “interview” historical figures by prompting ChatGPT to respond as Abraham Lincoln or Frederick Douglass.
• Science: AI can break down difficult chemistry equations step by step, helping students understand the logic behind chemical reactions.
• English: AI can help students brainstorm essay topics and organize their ideas without writing the entire essay for them.

Incorporating AI and critical thinking into lessons ensures that students actively engage with the material rather than passively accepting information. However, students must learn to fact-check AI-generated content—since AI can produce incorrect or misleading responses (known as “hallucinations”).

Where AI Should and Shouldn’t Be Used

Encouraged Uses of AI in the Classroom

While using AI in education can be beneficial, it’s important to establish clear guidelines for ethical AI use:

1. Enhancing Understanding
   
   • Students can use AI to rephrase explanations, break down complex concepts, and provide examples tailored to their learning styles.
   • Example: A student trying to learn Spanish can use ChatGPT to get specific examples of different verb conjugations, helping them understand how to correctly use verbs in different tenses and contexts.
2. Exploring and Communicating Ideas
   
   • AI can help students organize thoughts before writing essays or presentations.
   • Example: Instead of generating an entire essay, students can use ChatGPT to create an outline and refine their thesis statements. It can also act as an assistant by asking the student questions to prompt further thinking, helping them expand on their ideas and structure a more thoughtful outline for their essay.
3. Overcoming Writer’s Block
   
   • AI can suggest different approaches to an assignment, helping students find a starting point without doing the work for them.

When AI Should Be Limited

While AI can support student learning, it should not replace essential academic skills like critical thinking, problem-solving, and independent writing. Should AI be used in classrooms for every assignment? No. Here’s where teachers should set limits:

• During exams and assessments: AI should not be used when students need to demonstrate personal understanding.
• First-draft writing exercises: Students should generate original content before refining it with AI.
• Group discussions and debates: Students should form and articulate their own opinions without AI assistance.

By balancing AI-assisted learning with traditional methods, educators can ensure students develop both technological and critical thinking skills.

Preventing AI Misuse and Cheating Concerns

A major concern among educators is whether students will use AI dishonestly. While banning AI in schools might seem like a solution, it is ultimately counterproductive—students will find ways to use it regardless. Instead, a structured approach can regulate AI use while maintaining academic integrity.

Strategies for Ethical AI Use in Education

1. Require Students to Show Their Work
   
   • Encourage students to submit their AI-generated interactions alongside their original work. This transparency helps teachers see how AI was used in the learning or writing process.
2. Mix AI-Assisted and Traditional Learning
   
   • Use a blend of digital assignments, handwritten essays, and in-class discussions to prevent overreliance on AI.
   • Example: A history teacher could assign a handwritten essay on one topic and allow AI-assisted research for another, comparing the quality of insights in both.
3. Encourage AI Fact-Checking and Critical Analysis
   
   • Make students responsible for verifying AI-generated information.
   • Example: Assign students to identify errors in ChatGPT’s responses as a classroom activity.

‍

Teaching AI Literacy

Instead of fearing AI, educators should focus on teaching students how to use it responsibly. Schools should integrate AI literacy for students into their curricula, ensuring young learners understand the capabilities, limitations, and ethical considerations of AI.

Introducing Mastery Coding’s AI Essentials Course

To help educators prepare students for the future, Mastery Coding offers AI Essentials, a 10-hour video-based course designed to introduce students to artificial intelligence concepts and ethical AI use.

What Students Will Learn in AI Essentials:

• The fundamentals of machine learning and neural networks.
• How different AI systems are created and used.
• How to responsibly and effectively use generative AI tools in education and beyond.
• Ethical concerns surrounding AI, including bias, misinformation, and digital responsibility.

By integrating AI Essentials into classrooms, educators can ensure students are not just AI users but AI-literate thinkers.

Conclusion

Should students use ChatGPT? Yes—but with structure, transparency, and critical thinking. Rather than banning AI, educators should teach students how to use it ethically, responsibly, and effectively.

By implementing AI thoughtfully, we can ensure that students develop the skills they need to thrive in an AI-powered world. And with Mastery Coding’s AI Essentials course, educators have the perfect tool to prepare students for a future where AI is an integral part of learning and work.

‍